SIGNS & SYMBOLS

Well, I finally decided to enter the 21st century – the Richardson household signed up for Netflix this past weekend.
And, through cyberspace, I then proceeded to go back almost into the middle ages - I just finished watching Into Great Silence on my laptop. If Fast & Furious – Tokyo Drift is your favorite movie, this 2 hour and 41 minute film might not be your cup of tea. My seventeen year old son, Jacob, walked through while I was watching, looked at it for a moment, and said something along the lines of, “so, Dad, you’re watching old monks doing boring things.” I tried to ignore him as that often is how he describes me.
This documentary, by Philip Gröning, is about the monastery of Grand Chartreuse in the French Alps. Gröning spent six months with the monks, living as they live, filming everyday life as they live it - there’s no voiceover, no musical soundtrack, no artificial lighting, and definitely no explosions or car chases.
There is one scene in the film in which there is dialogue – occasionally “the fathers” go for a walk and are permitted to talk with one another. In this scene, they are discussing their custom of hand-washing prior to their shared meal (most meals are eaten solitarily in their cells). It’s clearly a ritual – single file, they walk by a trickling spigot, pass their fingers through some water, and then wipe their hands on a large linen cloth prior to entering the refectory (that’s monk-speak for “dining room”).
Some of them seem ready to do away with the tradition – they feel that it serves little purpose, as they are not really washing their hands. But then one of them says,
“Our entire life, the whole liturgy and everything ceremonial, are symbols. If you abolish the symbols, you tear down the walls of your own house.”
He goes on – “When we abolish the signs, we lose our orientation. Instead, we should search for the meanings…The signs are not to be questioned, but we are.”
And lastly – “The error is not to be found in hand-washing, but in our minds.” Let those last two statements sink in for a moment.
“The signs are not to be questioned, but we are.” “The error is not to be found in hand-washing, but in our minds.”
Far too often, as a culture, we are far too ready to cast traditions, or things, or even people aside, because they no longer fit into our notion of what we believe life should be like today. I deeply appreciate this reminder to look inside of me for the problem, and not assume too quickly that the issue is the tradition or the thing or that person I may think I can do without in my life.
Yes, I am the one to be questioned – the error is most often in my mind, and not in the liturgy, or the teachings of the Church through the ages, and definitely not in the Scriptures. As someone has said, “It is not we who read the Scriptures – the Scriptures read us.”
The entire film resonates with its recall to simpler life – to borrow Brother Lawrence’s phrase, to practicing the presence of God in each moment of daily life. The monks kneel in their cells on wooden prayer desks (with no kneeler cushions!) for extended prayer time. They sit in silence in their cells for most meals, bread, soup, fresh fruit, water, alone with only their thoughts and God as companions, looking out on the changing seasons as seen through a small window or an open door.
The film itself is sacramental – an outward and visible sign of inward and spiritual grace.
So, the next time you have 2 hours and 41 minutes on your hands, and want to be reminded of what is really important in life, and don’t mind letting some old (and young) monks doing boring things be the ones to remind you, sign up for Netflix and watch Into Great Silence on your computer. Or, go old school, and let them send it to your house. I for one can always use a little more middle ages in my 2008-paced life.
Labels: movies, sacraments, symbols

3 Comments:
This is a wonderful film, and I've been urging it folks for a long time now - I actually saw it on the "big screen" at the Belcourt in Nashville. I got to talk about it a bit recently when I gave a Lenten talk on the spiritual discipline of solitude at Holy Comforter, Sumter.
Blessings - Spud
Spudrick!
My first comment! Great to hear from you - it probably was you who planted the seed in my little pea-field brain to want to see this film. All I could remember was "there's a film out there that I heard about and I want to see it and it's something about monks and silence" - I googled "movie monks silence" and found it. If that was you, thanks. I fully agree.
Blessings back atcha. - F+
Matthew Lickona and Ernie Grimm had a great little discussion of the film that intersects nicely with what you had to say (can't remember how to properly put in the html stuff for a link, but a little googling will turn up the source):
Ernie: I was watching this last night when I got up to get an orange. Eating oranges, or anything else for that mater, had never been a spiritual occurrence for me until last night. But after an hour and a half of that movie, I had a sense of how slicing and eating the orange, wiping the juice from my mouth, throwing away the peels, rinsing the bowl, and placing it in the strainer could be spiritualized. I've never enjoyed an orange quite so much. Do I sound like an idiot?
Matthew: No more than usual. But hearing that from you, and thinking about the scenes that no doubt inspired it, I find myself thinking of Thoreau, who went to the woods to live deliberately, so that when it came time for him to die, he would not find that he had not lived. The monks are doing that in spades. They have, as the film reminds us again and again, taken Christ to heart when He said, "Unless you give up everything, you cannot be my disciple." But in giving up everything, they have gained a remarkable sense of meaning. It shows when they discuss handwashing. "It wouldn't be a big deal to get rid of something useless," says one. "Our entire life is symbols," answers another. "The entire liturgy and every ceremonial are symbols. If you abolish the symbols, then you tear down the walls of your own house." They have made of their lives a symbol -- that is, they have given the whole of their life a meaning. They are, as the old monk says, entirely at God's disposal -- listening for him, waiting on him. The planes pass by overhead, and they look ridiculous by comparison.
Post a Comment
<< Home